MAKE BAN APPEALS PUBLIC

First of all, they are intresting to read and you can know when one of your friends got banned.
Secondly, they bring back laughs. *cough* *cough* p00pbl0cks *cough* *cough*
You are probably going to make suggestions private soon, then ban requests.
If you don't accept this, shame on you.

EDIT: Just simply make them so you can't post on them.

 

+1

Don't know why it was made private. The moderators approval thing was good enough.

 

because a troll made 50 ban appeals with sex refs in them and drug refs and stupid crap

 

then they should moderate and accept appeals to be public. It was fun to go over them .

 

They are supposed to come back, they were supposed to come back the day after the mess was resolved. Reggles just hasn't done it yet.

 

Then they'd better do it quick. Or else.

 

They should.
While annoying to moderate toll appeals, it is better to see ban appeals in case I have something to say about it.

Like about a week before appeals were taken down and made private, I posted on someone's appeal about an alt account they missed in the mess of his IP.

I was talking to klutch last night, we both agreed on the same issue. If Player1 gets banned, he tells me over skype 'lol I'm gonna appeal and when it's accepted I'm gonna trash the server' I should be able to see that guys appeal and go hey wait, this is a terrible idea, here's what he said to me.

This also works with a theft. If player1 stole from me, I got him banned and he appeals, we can then talk about it in an appeal, because he can be unbanned if he gives me my stuff back, I'm more than willing to work that out.

 

The ban appeal bot was never going to work out in the first place.

 

To be honest, I don't think this is going to happen. The reason being is that there is no need for it to be public. It is staff who make the decisions and players can't post on them anyway. If they have proof, we will bring them into the situation. End of

 

I have read that

 

Then your 'there is no reason, end of story' post is invalid. There are clear reasons for it to be public, as well as the fact that it's there for players to learn rules (don't say that's not how to do it, I read ban appeals to learn the rules better), and for entertainment and knowledge purposes.

 

Have you even read what I have put? You have only stated the first 4 worlds and the last 3. Obviously you haven't actually seen what I have put.

 

Wow. We have a smartalec helper.
I like it.

I've been told by klutch it will, but eh Idk if you have so I'll leave it

- I can see and know who's banned and why
-I can post any extra info I have that staff do not.
- if the appeal is related to me (such as if you were banned and you stole from me) I should be able to post there and maybe we can work it out
- Entertainment, it's a stupid reason but I'll put it here.

Aye, it is staff who make this decision, but let's pull an example.
You, jamez, you get banned for hacking 2 months ago. You have me on skype and we talk to each other occasionally. You tell me you're going to appeal, and if it gets accepted you're going to hack again.
So now your appeal is up. I cannot see it, so I have no reason to tell the staff what you said. Is the fact that I know you're going to hack again not related and important?
*was example not true don't use that against him ever just a disclaimer*

Haaaaah.
Haaah.
Hah.
Staff can be and should be open to a discussion and question. You can't just pull 'because I said so.' here. It's ridiculous.

 

Solution: the appeal bot's posts have to be approved before the public can see them.

Or don't use the damn bot system at all. Have the banned players send an email to [email protected] and review it in the staff chat. Just because an incident happened once, doesn't mean we should lock it down for everyone.

 

Fair enough. Can't argue with that

 

How are you supposed to know what players have proof?

 

Unless it was you who was banned, ban appeals don't affect any of you. You have no real need to see them, you just want to laugh and entertain yourselves on other people's misfortunes.

-1 because how this suggestion was titled, and how the OP posted his first comment.