If you’re suggesting the credibility of the reporter be in question, I completely agree. In too many cases, the first person to file a modreq or contact staff gets benefit of the doubt that they were the person being wronged (while this is terrible; it is not common. Think I noticed it maybe two times total while I was a helper).
Is this the general idea?
If so, I believe you are trying to address a problem, but your solution is too extreme.