What do you guys think about these Eco plugins?

PainCakexx1997

http://mods.curse.com/bukkit-plugins/minecraft/advancedeco

http://mods.curse.com/bukkit-plugins/minecraft/serenityloans

Please give me your honest opinion and what you guys think is good and bad about the plugins. And last which of these would you install/not install on the server and why/why not.

WeAreNumberUno

Advanced Eco seems like its basically what we have now. It has a few differences, but they seem all to be matters of preference.

Serenity loans seems like it would just be a more streemlined version of what some people already do, I have seen numerous people giving loans, and it is a great way to make money.

CluelessKlutz

I don't really care for the first one as much. It just seems like personal preference over the one we already have.

The second one would be nice. Yes, players are taking out loans already, but is rather informal and risky because staff have said they cannot verify loans.

zsuzsu1

-1 for eco one:
pros:
xp banks
cons:
job req and apps that wouldn't allow new players to join jobs right away
work limits...
intrest...
roxy has 150mil x 0.01% per month/day is a lot
LMFAO uniforms
-1 for loan one

WeAreNumberUno

they cannot verify loans.
~ @CluelessKlutz

Use contracts.

roxy has 150mil
~ @zsuzsu1

Not saying I disagree with what you said, but using one example of one super rich person is dumb.