I only went to the dungeon to level up my hunter job, plus killing some players. I never came in for the loot (except maybe the op diamonds)
Solution to this problem
It ruined many items value.....Dungeon was just as bad as /fix.
~ @Summers
Easy solution would make iron armor / sword, iron ores, up to 1 emerald at most per chest and nothing like diamonds or gold. Even the Armor / sword can have some enchantments from anything to god tier (If you're extremely lucky)
Also, I was reading about some people worried about the mob drops being "too common" Why not just remove the Mob drops completely in dungeon, or make them not every drop? Just nerf the drops to like 10% chance or something like that. Or maybe I was thinking of another thread? Idc keeping this to make sure if someone actually cared about drops then this part would not be wasted.
The annoying things I've found in old dungeon:
If there is a new dungeon please: Make spawns actually random. I hate it when someone jumps into the portal right after me and spawn right next to me to try to get a free kill.
Toggle explosions off. I'm pretty sure I wasn't the only one annoyed by the creeper who blew you into a hole that you cannot get out of? Then the blocks tried to suffocate you :/
I made this post @ 3am, so I probably won't remember it when I wake up.
Dungeon was very fun. It is one of the original reasons I decided to check out towny (to store my loot). I believe it can easily be added back without destroying the economy. Instead of dropping items at random, it should have the same map, but have loot rebalancing. In my opinion, if it only gives mob drops, and "special" items like enchanted iron armor (at best), it could make new players feel like they can make it on the server. Before you all start saying this would kill the iron market, let me just remind you of two things: iron farms, and it's iron armor, not something that can only be made of iron.
~ @CluelessKlutz
Actually, couldn't have said it better myself. Sorry I typed this all and then found your comment.
+1 to dungeon as long as it gets rebalanced.