Splash Pots

baku

Dunno if this thread has already been created, (it probably has), but come on. It's been a long time since splash potions were nerfed, and although I understand why they were nerfed in the first place, simply disabling all splash potions isn't a good permanent solution. Just because harming potions got the crap abused out of them doesn't mean all splash pots (like insta health II, most prominently), need to be disabled. There has to be a way to only disable the harming effects, or debuff effects in general. I think this nerf has gone on for way too long, and in my personal opinion, is kind of ruining the pvp environment.

If you think I was wrong, don't be a 5 year old and leave hate, just tell me otherwise. Peace.
Wow I used the word "nerf" way 2 much in this thread

Foretvert

@KlutchDecals wanted me to make a list about this a while back, so here it is. My list is broken down into different tiers of competitive play, with the first category being most competitive and the last being quite the contrary. I have also underlined my opinion of each category of potions having taken into consideration MeepCraft's level of PvP play.

Tier 1: Here are the following potions that should not be re-enabled at all:

Splash Harming & Splash Harming II
Splash Poison II & Splash Poison Extended
Strength II & Splash Strength II
Invisibility, Invisibility Extended, Splash Invisibility, and Splash Invisibility Extended

Tier 2: Here are potions that I would deem acceptable but others might not like, so they should probably be disabled:

Splash Poison

Tier 3: Here are potions that I feel more PvPers would deem acceptable and I recommend these be enabled:

Strength, Strength Extended, Splash Strength, Splash Strength Extended
Splash Potion of Weakness & Splash Potion of Weakness Extended
Splash Potion of Slowness Extended

The last tier of potions includes anything that I did not mention. This is includes specifically, but not limited to, Splash Potions of Healing II, Splash Potions of Slowness, and Splash Potions of Regeneration II. Depending upon what the admins think the level of play should be, they should go about banning tier by tier. If it were me and I were thinking of MeepCraft's best interests, I would ban Tier 1 and Tier 2, but I would allow Tier 3.

Do realize these tiers are entirely my own opinion and realize that I am entitled to my opinion just as you are entitled to yours. That said, if you think a certain potion should be placed in a different tier or if you want me to clarify why I placed a certain potion in a particular tier, feel free to comment. I simply wanted to create an infrastructure to re-enable splash potions and make terrarium better.

Redolwolf

yes.

legendcaleb

I don't even mind Poison II because it's not even that strong, but if I had to choose I'd ban only tier 1, if even.

KlutchDecals

We just redid terrarium, ive sent the list to dblo of the potions a few days ago. Hes super busy irl atm but will get to it soon.

Eggwall01

Thanks for your efforts to make PVP better, guys! Although we don't always seem to show it, I'd like you to know that your efforts aren't in vain and that we do indeed appreciate the work you do for the server.